Carrie Pilby (Movie)

1 Min Read
Title — Carrie Pilby
Available on — Netflix, Amazon Video, Vudu, Microsoft Store, Google Play Movies, YouTube
Production Country — United States
Release Date — 2016
A socially awkward 19-year-old genius makes big plans to step out of her shell and make a friend, get a job and – maybe – even go on a date.

🪶 Story & Synopsis

“Carrie Pilby,” directed by Susan Johnson and based on the novel by Caren Lissner, follows the story of Carrie, a 19-year-old Harvard graduate portrayed by the talented Bel Powley. Carrie is a gifted individual who struggles to navigate the complexities of morality, relationships, and life outside her New York apartment.

Despite her intelligence, Carrie finds herself isolated due to her high standards, lacking both a job and meaningful friendships. At the advice of her therapist, she embarks on a journey to create a five-point plan to help her find her way in the world.

Throughout the film, Carrie’s character is brought to life by Powley’s compelling performance, showcasing both her quirks and imperfections. The screenplay by Kara Holden captures Carrie’s self-conscious dialogue and inner turmoil, providing a glimpse into the challenges faced by a young woman struggling to find her place in the world.

As Carrie navigates blind dates, encounters with well-meaning coworkers, and attempts to broaden her horizons, the audience is drawn into her world of self-discovery and personal growth. Through it all, Carrie’s journey is marked by moments of humor, introspection, and a deep exploration of what it means to truly connect with others.

🧑 Cast & Crew

Bel Powley, Nathan Lane, Vanessa Bayer, Gabriel Byrne, Jason Ritter, Colin O’Donoghue, William Moseley, Desmin Borges

Actor Role
Bel Powley Carrie Pilby
Vanessa Bayer Tara
Colin O’Donoghue David Harrison
William Moseley Cy
Jason Ritter Matt
Desmin Borges Douglas
Poorna Jagannathan Fliss
Nathan Lane Dr. Petrov
Gabriel Byrne Mr. Pilby

💬 Reviews and feedback

Hey movie buffs! Ready to dive into the quirky, whimsical world of Carrie Pilby? Imagine if your brain was a combination of Sherlock Holmes’ intellect and Bridget Jones’ romantic escapades. Intrigued? Buckle up, because we’re about to embark on a journey through the streets of Manhattan with none other than Carrie Pilby herself.

Plot, Themes, and Tone:

First things first: Is it worth watching “Carrie Pilby”? This film is like a warm cup of cocoa on a rainy day – comforting, albeit with a slightly sweet aftertaste that might not suit everyone. The plot revolves around Carrie (Bel Powley), an intellectually gifted 19-year-old Harvard graduate struggling to find her footing in the chaotic world outside academia. Picture Sheldon Cooper with a splash of Elizabeth Bennet’s charm. She’s trying to make sense of morality, relationships, and sex in the big bad city of New York.

The movie is based on the novel by Caren Lissner and is suitable for audiences aged 12+ and mature 11-year-olds. It’s worth noting that while it’s not based on a true story, the character of Carrie is inspired by various people Lissner has met over the years in NYC.

Themes? Oh boy! This film tackles themes like loneliness, self-discovery, and finding one’s moral compass. It resonates particularly well with anyone who’s ever felt alone in a bustling city or struggled to align their intellectual ideals with real-world relationships.

Acting and Characters:

Bel Powley as Carrie is an absolute gem. She brings an authentic vulnerability to her role that makes you root for her despite her often prickly demeanor. She’s intelligent and pretty but highly guarded – think Elsa from “Frozen” but without the icy superpowers.

Other characters include Cy (William Moseley), who’s essentially a walking rom-com trope but manages to be endearing nonetheless. Then there’s Carrie’s therapist (Nathan Lane), who plays his part with just the right amount of quirkiness without tipping into caricature territory.

Direction and Cinematography:

Susan Johnson directs this coming-of-age tale with a light touch that balances melancholy and wackiness quite well – even if it does swing wildly at times (hello mood swings!). The cinematography captures New York City beautifully; it’s almost like another character in the film.


The soundtrack complements the film perfectly – upbeat when it needs to be, reflective during quieter moments. It doesn’t steal the spotlight but enhances each scene subtly.

Binge-Watching Tips:

  • Binge-Watching Tip #1: Keep some tissues handy! While it’s mostly upbeat, there are moments that tug at your heartstrings unexpectedly.
  • Binge-Watching Tip #2: Pair this movie with some comfort food – pizza or ice cream works wonders!
  • Binge-Watching Tip #3: Watch it alone or with someone who appreciates quirky indie films; it’s definitely more enjoyable that way!

Production Design and Special Effects:

The production design reflects Carrie’s internal chaos beautifully through her cluttered apartment contrasted against clean-cut scenes from her past life at Harvard. Special effects are minimal but effective where used – no CGI monsters here folks!

Pace and Editing:

The pacing can be uneven at times; certain scenes drag while others whiz by too quickly leaving you wanting more depth or closure on subplots introduced briefly earlier on.


The dialogues are witty yet poignant when needed – they capture Carrie’s sardonic wit perfectly while also allowing glimpses into deeper emotional layers beneath her tough exterior façade.

Your Turn!

  • If you could have dinner with any character from “Carrie Pilby”, who would it be?
  • This movie reminded me so much of…. Share your thoughts! Did you see elements similar to “The Perks of Being A Wallflower” or perhaps “Juno”?


“Carrie Pilby” may not rise above mediocrity for everyone but its charm lies precisely within these imperfections making us reflect upon our own flaws & complexities navigating through life’s labyrinthine paths… So if you’re feeling like giving yourself some much-needed TLC wrapped around soothing laughter then do give ‘Carrie’ shot… You might just end up loving yourself bit more afterwards just as she learns herself gradually throughout journey…

I’d give “Carrie Pilby” a solid 7/10 . Not perfect by any means but worth investing time especially those quiet introspective evenings where all need little dose empathy mixed humor thrown generously together creating perfect blend comforting warmth…</blockquote

Pros Cons
Upbeat comedy Mediocre rom-com
Suitable for 12+ audience Does not rise above mediocrity
Based on a novel Relationships with older people may not appeal to all viewers
Coming-of-age theme Character development may lack depth
Happy and upbeat film Some characters may come off as one-dimensional


  • Carrie Pilby (film) - Wikipedia

    Carrie Pilbyis a 2016 American comedy-drama film directed by Susan Johnson and written by Kara Holden and Dean Craig, based on the best-selling novel of the same name by Caren Lissner. The film stars Bel Powley, Nathan Lane, Gabriel Byrne, Jason Ritter, William Moseley, Vanessa Bayer, and Colin O’Donoghue. Principal photography began on December 14, 2015, in New York City.

    Carrie Pilby
    Directed by Susan Johnson
    Screenplay by
    • Kara Holden
    • Dean Craig
    Based on Carrie Pilby

    by Caren Lissner

  • Carrie Pilby (2016) - IMDb


    • verdandee
    • Dec 1, 2021
    • How long is Carrie Pilby?Powered by Alexa

    DetailsBox office

    • Gross US & Canada
      • $18,957
    • Opening weekend US & Canada
      • $13,944
      • Apr 2, 2017
    • Gross worldwide
      • $28,430
    • Runtime1 hour 38 minutes
    • Color

    Contribute to this page

    Suggest an edit or add missing content

  • Carrie Pilby movie review & film summary (2017) | Roger Ebert

    Take that character and put it in the body of a 19-year-old woman and you have “Carrie Pilby.”It’s a clever idea with some self-conscious dialogue that probably played better on the page than it does on the screen; the debut feature from director Susan Johnson, with a screenplay by Kara Holden, is based on the Young Adult novel of the same name by Caren Lissner. But as the title character, Bel Powley is so enormously compelling that she breathes life into Carrie’s quirks and the story’s contrivances. And it’s clear that the women behind the scenes have great affection for Carrie in all her self-sabotaging imperfections.

  • Carrie Pilby | Rotten Tomatoes

    Carrie Pilbyis rough around the edges but very endearing as Bel Powley delivers a compelling performance that’s often enough to push past contrived notions.

    Carrie PilbyWhere to WatchCarrie Pilby

    Watch Carrie Pilby with a subscription on Netflix, rent on Fandango at Home, Prime Video, or buy on Fandango at Home, Prime Video.

    What to KnowCritics ReviewsAudience ReviewsCast & Crew

    Susan JohnsonDirectorBel PowleyCarrie PilbyGabriel ByrneMr. PilbyNathan LaneDr. PetrovJason RitterMattVanessa BayerTara

⚠️ Explanation (Spoiler)

“Carrie Pilby” is a delightful movie that takes a familiar character trope of a cantankerous misanthrope and flips it by placing it in the body of a 19-year-old woman named Carrie Pilby. The film, directed by Susan Johnson and based on the Young Adult novel by Caren Lissner, follows Carrie, brilliantly portrayed by Bel Powley, as she navigates her way through life as a highly intelligent but socially awkward young woman.

Carrie is portrayed as the smartest person in the room but struggles with happiness and human connections. Despite her sharp wit and analytical mind, she finds it challenging to understand herself and form relationships. Her therapist, played by Nathan Lane, encourages her to step out of her comfort zone and gives her a to-do list to help her engage with the world around her.

Throughout the movie, Carrie embarks on a series of adventures that include a blind date, interactions with quirky co-workers, and getting to know the boy next door. These experiences push her to confront her loneliness and confront her own vulnerabilities. The film beautifully balances moments of humor and depth, especially through flashbacks to Carrie’s past relationships, adding layers to her character.

Bel Powley’s performance as Carrie is captivating, bringing depth and charm to the character. Her on-screen presence keeps the audience engaged even during moments that may seem less believable. The movie is elevated by Powley’s portrayal of Carrie and her ability to breathe life into the character’s quirks and complexities.

“Carrie Pilby” is a heartfelt exploration of self-discovery, friendship, and the complexities of human connection. It beautifully captures the journey of a young woman coming to terms with her place in the world and learning to open her heart to the possibility of happiness. With a mix of humor, warmth, and sincerity, the film offers a refreshing take on the coming-of-age genre.

👪 Parents Guide & Age Rating


Age Rating:

Carrie Pilby movie is rated as mild with no nudity or obvious sex scenes shown. The content is suitable for teenagers aged 14 and above.

Parental Guide:

Carrie Pilby is a coming-of-age comedy-drama film that follows the story of a 19-year-old Harvard graduate who struggles to navigate relationships, morality, and leaving her apartment. Here is a detailed parental guide to help you decide if this movie is suitable for your teenager:

  • Sex & Nudity: There are no nudity or explicit sex scenes in the movie. In one scene, a man unbuttons and takes off Carrie’s shirt, revealing her bra briefly. Another scene shows Carrie at age 16 lying on a bed with her college professor, both fully covered by blankets.
  • Violence & Gore: The movie does not contain any graphic violence or gore. It focuses more on the emotional and mental struggles of the main character.
  • Profanity: The film includes mild language, with occasional use of profanity such as damn, hell, and ass.
  • Alcohol/Drugs/Smoking: There are scenes showing social drinking in a bar setting, but no explicit drug use or smoking is depicted.
  • Frightening/Intense Scenes: The movie does not have any intense or frightening scenes. It primarily deals with themes of self-discovery and personal growth.

Overall, Carrie Pilby is a thought-provoking film that can be beneficial for older teens, especially those interested in character-driven stories. While there are some mature themes and situations, the movie offers a positive message about self-acceptance and personal development.

📺 Streaming and where to watch

streaming service extra information
Netflix You can watch Carrie Pilby on Netflix basic with Ads.
Amazon Video You can buy or rent Carrie Pilby on Amazon Video.
Vudu You can buy or rent Carrie Pilby on Vudu.
Microsoft Store You can buy or rent Carrie Pilby on Microsoft Store.
Google Play Movies You can buy or rent Carrie Pilby on Google Play Movies.
YouTube You can buy or rent Carrie Pilby on YouTube.

❝ Quotes and Cult

  • There's a perfectly good reason I don't have any friends. Friends are people. And people are dishonest, ingenuine, and let's face it, not that smart.
    Carrie Pilby
  • I'd appreciate you not listening in on my sessions. Carrie Pilby: I'm sorry. The door was just flat enough for my ear.
    Carrie Pilby
  • Come on, smart AND pretty? You must be killing it out there. Do you have a boyfriend? Carrie Pilby: Is that really your next question?

🤖Carrie Pilby Reddit Talks

Carrie Pilby, a coming-of-age film, follows the journey of a 19-year-old prodigy as she navigates the complexities of life beyond academia. Based on the young adult novel of the same name, the movie has garnered mixed reactions on social media platforms like Reddit.

Character and Story Appreciation:

Many viewers have praised the film’s portrayal of Carrie Pilby, a highly intelligent and socially awkward young woman. Her struggles to connect with others and find her place in the world resonate with many, particularly those who identify with being on the autistic spectrum. The film’s exploration of loneliness, self-discovery, and the challenges of growing up has been widely appreciated.

Formulaic Structure and Predictability:

However, some critics have pointed out the film’s somewhat formulaic structure, which follows Carrie as she completes a list of goals in order to improve her social and emotional well-being. This predictable plotline has been seen as a weakness by some, who argue that it limits the film’s potential for depth and originality.

Casting and Performances:

Bel Powley’s performance as Carrie Pilby has been widely praised. Viewers have commended her ability to capture the character’s intelligence, vulnerability, and dry wit. The supporting cast, including Nathan Lane and Vanessa Bayer, also received positive reviews for their performances.

Mental Health Representation:

The film’s portrayal of mental health issues has been a topic of discussion among viewers. Some have praised the movie for its sensitive and nuanced depiction of Carrie’s struggles with anxiety and depression. Others have expressed concern that the film may perpetuate stereotypes or simplify the complexities of mental illness.

Comparison to Other Films:

Comparisons have been drawn between Carrie Pilby and other films that explore similar themes, such as “The Diary of a Teenage Girl” and “Perks of Being a Wallflower.” While some viewers see Carrie Pilby as a worthy addition to this genre, others argue that it fails to offer anything particularly new or groundbreaking.

Audience Reception:

Overall, Carrie Pilby has received a mixed reception from Reddit users. While many appreciate the film’s unique perspective, strong performances, and positive representation of mental health, others find it predictable and lacking in originality. The film’s strengths and weaknesses have been debated, but it has undoubtedly sparked conversations about the challenges and complexities of young adulthood.

Top discussions

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Is Carrie Pilby suitable for children to watch?

The movie Carrie Pilby is suitable for children aged 12 and above, and can also be appropriate for mature 11-year-olds.

Is Carrie Pilby based on a true story?

The film is based on the novel Carrie Pilby by Caren Lissner. The character of Carrie is inspired by several people the author met in New York City over the years.

Who is the film Carrie Pilby geared towards?

Carrie Pilby is a coming-of-age film that delves into the main character’s relationships with older individuals, making it appealing to a broad audience.

What is the movie Carrie Pilby about?

Carrie Pilby follows the story of a gifted woman who navigates the complexities of morality, relationships, sex, and leaving her New York apartment after graduating from Harvard at 19. Her therapist suggests she create a five-point plan to get her life on track.

Where was the movie Carrie Pilby filmed?

Carrie Pilby was filmed during the Christmas season in New York City, aligning with the story’s timeline. The producers utilized the holiday season to save costs on set construction due to the indie film budget.

Is Carrie Pilby available on Netflix?

You can watch Carrie Pilby on Netflix with a subscription, rent it on Fandango at Home or Prime Video, or purchase it on Fandango at Home or Prime Video.

🔀 Recommended Movie and TV Show

  1. Chronically Metropolitan: A young writer returns to New York City to face his past and confront his dysfunctional family.
  2. The Edge of Seventeen: High school junior Nadine navigates the awkward and humorous challenges of adolescence.
  3. Hard Sell: A high school student forms an unlikely friendship with a Wall Street executive.
  4. The Devil Wears Prada (2006): A young woman lands a job as an assistant to a powerful fashion magazine editor.
  5. The Women (2008): A wealthy New Yorker’s life is turned upside down when she discovers her husband’s infidelity.
  6. 10 Things I Hate About You (1999): A modern adaptation of Shakespeare’s “The Taming of the Shrew” set in a high school.
  7. Breaking & Exiting (2018): A burglar ends up forming a unique bond with a suicidal woman.
  8. Staten Island: A young woman navigates life and love in New York City.

Wallpapers & Media

🔥 Audience Trends

✨ Discover more titles

✍️ Contribute to this page